Shoujo Track: Are girls still reading shoujo manga?

September 20, 2009  |  Blog
This entry is part 1 of 1 in the series Shoujo Tracks

This is part of the series:

Shoujo Tracks

  • Shoujo Track: Are girls still reading shoujo manga?

While talking about the manga canon with some friends, I realized that most of my girl friends were dropping more shounen titles in their canon than a shoujo manga. And when I asked why they seem to have a particular distaste for the genre. Is it me or a good number of girls would sooner pick a shounen or seinen manga than pick up a shoujo manga to read? Somehow that strikes me wrong. Because if the shoujo manga market is supposed to target a young girl and this said target would rather read another thing… does that mean that the content of shoujo manga no longer caters to the girl’s heart? Or am I assuming too much that international readers are similar to Japanese readers?

Or… am I really surrounded by fujoshis?

Hence, here’s a poll. I’m mildly curious on the taste of foreign female readers. I want you guys to answer honestly and maybe instinctively. Don’t try to think of gajillion ifs and buts when you answer. The question is rather straightforward. I will not entertain loopholes on this once since it’s a rather informal question and I’d like to see what you guys would answer in an instant. There is no ‘both’. Answer it in the same way that you would pick that manga off a shelf. Which one would you pick first?

If you have your reasons, please comment on why you gave your answer. Certainly it will all boil down to taste. Then please share with me what are your tastes in manga? What is it that shoujo has or lacks that makes you prefer or not prefer the genre at all. The comments are optional but I’d highly appreciate it if you give your two cents since I’m rather interested on what sways your choice or your taste. I’m quite sure that the answers here will lead me to another question, but for now, let’s see how this one rolls.

I trust that only girls will reply in this poll. So boys, even if you love shoujo, you can’t answer the poll. I’m looking at you, Pao. And maybe Boss. If my answers are rigged… :< You guys suck.

For the girls, spread the poll around. I’d like to get a variety of answers and comments.

Anyway, here goes:

Omitting BL from the shoujo manga genre, would you read a shoujo manga over a shounen/seinen title?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Popularity: 5% [?]

Related posts:

Spotting the Difference
An interview with Nakamura-sensei at Manga no Chikara
Why change something that's already as good as it is?

  • http://myspace.com/hyperactiveotakuaddict taki-desu

    what can i say? i got tired of the big eyed sparkles and protagonist that bugged me to no end. yes while i am a fujoshi, i have to say that reading a shonen is more exciting to me and that shojo was the sort of manga i read at the start of my hobby. now that i cosplay, read them doujins and started collecting my figurines of all i can, i started more of the bl then again i just recently bought the whole season of gantz and am dying to get some gar titles in my shelf.
    anyway if i do read a shoujo its for the comedy relief, and that the main character doesn’t bug me. im tired of the whole cliche attributes i recall during my first time wandering into the manga scene.